Understanding Bore Scoring in Al-Si Cylinder Systems — Charles Navarro / PAGE 7
Normal wear of the Al-Si matrix can be described by the ultra-mild-wear (UMW) regime. The UMW · regime can be broken down into thr
Read extracted page text
OCR can contain errors. Check the original page image for exact wording, warnings and specifications.
Normal wear of the Al-Si matrix can be described by the ultra-mild-wear (UMW) regime. The UMW
regime can be broken down into three stages:
● Stage I: Silicon particles fracture and are embedded into the supporting aluminum matrix.
● Stage II: Increased wear occurs as exposed aluminum matrix is removed.
● Stage III: A smooth and stable surface supported by ultra-fine aluminum grains with a ZDDP and
molybdenum (moly) rich tribofilm forms followed by a reduction in wear and friction.
Along with proper lubrication, surface modification techniques must be applied to these components for use
in an Al-Si engine.37 Depending on what type of piston is used, cast or forged, and its silicon content,
extremely tight piston to cylinder clearances of 8 - 32 µm (0.0003-0.0012”) require durable piston skirt
coatings that reduce friction and prevent wear. The process, originally referred to as “tining”, provides a
thin coating on the piston skirt that provides a wear barrier between the aluminum piston and the aluminum
bore. These coatings are critical to the long-term reliability of aluminum cylinder bores. Due to the
abrasive nature of the Alusil or Lokasil sliding surface with its exposed silicon particles, when the piston
skirt coating fails, galling caused by aluminum on aluminum contact will occur. This will result in cylinder and
piston scoring and/or seizure, primarily on the thrust side of the piston skirt with localized wear starting at
the bottom of the bore (BDC) moving upwards towards the mid-stroke region on the corresponding
cylinder surface.38
When the UMW regime can no longer be supported, the severe wear regime begins the progression to
catastrophic surface failure.39 An area without sufficient silicon exposure or with more than 40% of the
primary silicon particles crushed40 will experience accelerated wear of the softer aluminum matrix that
supports it, resulting in premature engine failure from scuffing and scoring.41 When silicon particles
fracture and become dislodged from the Al-Si matrix, the aluminum substrate that supports the silicon
particles becomes pitted, generating a large amount of wear debris, accounting for high wear rates and
high total wear volume.42 Cold start conditions with insufficient lubrication and higher porosity from the
aforementioned pitting of the aluminum matrix further reduce scuffing resistance.43 The coefficient of
friction in the piston and liner system increases when surface finish roughness increases with highest areas of
37 Improved Engine Performance Via Use of Nickel Ceramic Composite Coatings (NCC Coat). K. Funatani, et al. Metal
Matrix Composites (Sp-1010). SAE Technical Paper Series 940852. 1984.
38 Friction and Wear of Tribo-Elements in Power Producing Units For IC Engines - A Review. Roop Lal, et al.
International Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology - Vol 14 no. 5 - August 2014.
39 Sliding wear behavior of eutectic Al-Si alloy under lubricated conditions: An investigation on the effect of ethanol
(E85) addition. Victor Vimalrajan Francis. University of Windsor.
40 The new Porsche 944 4-cylinder aluminum engine. Paul Hensler. Porsche AG. SAE International.
41 Replacing the Cast Iron Liners for Aluminum Engine Cylinder Blocks: A Comparative Assessment of Potential
Candidates. John Lenny Jr.
42 Wear of different material pairings for the cylinder liner - piston ring contact. Thomas Wopelka, et al. Industrial
Lubrication and Tribology. DOI 10.1108/ILT-07-2017-0218.
43 Sliding wear behavior of eutectic Al-Si alloy under lubricated conditions: An investigation on the effect of ethanol
(E85) addition. Victor Vimalrajan Francis. University of Windsor.
LN Engineering Technical Library. Copyright ©2019 LN Engineering LLC
This is a source reference. Confirm exact model applicability in the original material.
