Understanding Bore Scoring in Al-Si Cylinder Systems — Charles Navarro / PAGE 11
to full operating temperature in cold weather. As a point of reference, Mercedes restricts engine · performance at oil temperature
Read extracted page text
OCR can contain errors. Check the original page image for exact wording, warnings and specifications.
to full operating temperature in cold weather. As a point of reference, Mercedes restricts engine
performance at oil temperatures below 20°C (68°F) on AMG models.60
Just as Al-Si engines can be negatively affected by cold weather operation, at higher engine
temperatures the minimum oil film thickness (MOFT) required varies depending on the regime of lubrication
(hydrodynamic, mixed, or boundary) as well as the oil used. The struggle for engineers seeking higher fuel
economy is that higher viscosity oils cause higher viscous power losses, requiring either higher operating
temperatures or thinner oils to reduce these losses. Higher oil temperatures resulting in lower lubricant
viscosity help to reduce oil intrusion into the combustion chamber as well as evaporation and consumption,
reducing the likelihood of low speed pre-ignition (LSPI) in direct injected, forced induction engines.
Controlling liner temperatures have a direct effect on surface lubricant temperature, HC, and NOx
emissions, so an optimal temperature has to be found to balance emissions as well as thermal and frictional
losses. Frictional losses from the piston rings are at their lowest with a liner temperature of 80°C (176°F).,
but at higher temperatures, MOFT may transition lubrication from mixed to boundary layer, causing
increased friction due to asperity contact, such as the plastic deformation of the aluminum matrix of Al-Si
bores. A temperature increase of the liner from 80-120°C (176-248°F) can result in a 40-55% reduction
in MOFT mid-stroke, in areas where bore scoring can occur. In fact, once operating in boundary lubrication
regime, an increase of temperature has little effect in the MOFT, and it is the anti-wear additives like
ZDDP and moly that provide the needed wear protection for these surfaces in the cylinder system.61
With both extreme hot and cold operation, driving short distances, as well as mixed city and highway
driving, determining oil change intervals (OCI) is quite the challenge. With modern synthetics, most
manufacturers have extended their OCI to multiple years and 15,000 miles or more. GM in conjunction
with their DEXOS oils that are calibrated to their oil life monitoring system, utilize an oil health monitoring
system that continuously monitors engine-operating conditions.62 The system has proven itself to be very
accurate at estimating the remaining life of the engine oil to determine when to change oil. However, most
manufacturers still utilize time or mileage limits, whichever comes first. Some provide severe service
intervals, typically three to six months and 3,000 to 5,000 miles, and is especially important for vehicles
operated in colder and hotter climates alike.63 Even with a system as advanced as GM’s oil life monitor,
the only way to accurately measure an oil’s performance for a given application and the component health
lubricated by an oil is with regular used oil analysis. In Al-Si engines, knowing the primary wear metals
from the cylinder bores would be comprised of aluminum and silicon, regular testing can provide a
baseline wear profile for a given lubricant and engine combination. Not only is it possible to validate
changes to OCI and the effectiveness of lubricants used, but also to detect accelerated wear of the
aluminum matrix and silicon particles that support the Al-Si cylinder system.
60 2015 Mercedes S-Class Sedan Operators Manual. Driving - pg 189. Mercedes Benz USA.
61 The effect of cylinder liner operating temperature on frictional loss and engine emissions in piston ring conjunction.
R. Rhamani, et al. Wolfson School of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, Loughborough University,
Loughborough, Leicestershire, UK.
62https://assets.cobaltnitra.com/teams/repository/export/975/c7820afba1004895010145efa6b30/975c7820af
ba1004895010145efa6b30.pdf
63http://www.hastingsfilter.com/Literature/TSB/94-1R1.pdf
LN Engineering Technical Library. Copyright ©2019 LN Engineering LLC
This is a source reference. Confirm exact model applicability in the original material.
