Clutch in an automagic transmission? - 986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners

So I was driving around the other day contemplating why I have a tiptronic boxster instead of a manual one, and I got to thinking: What would happen if you just replaced the torque converter in the car with a nice, solid clutch? I've never opened up the tranny before but wouldn't it work essentially the same way as a sequential gearbox? the internals would be completely different, of course, but would they work? shifts would probably feel hella thumpier but I assume if you had a true sequential gearbox it would feel about the same. I'm not seriously thinking about doing this but I found it an interesting concept. Has anyone ever done this? and finally, why don't any street cars have sequential gearboxes?

A lot of guys do that to the 944

Wouldn't it have to be a wet clutch?

First without the torque converter there is no way to provide fluid pressure for the shifting. Then there would be the issue with loss of torque multiplication without the converter. Then somehow there needs to be a clutch pedal to operate the clutch... You could always go the other way around and go with a SMG trans, where there there is a computer that drives the solenoids and hydraulic valves... ie SMG for the BMWs Still, either way, kind of expensive to be putting so much money in a old car. Oh and yes clutches have been put into automatic trans in place of the torque converter, they were used to some success in drag racing in the late 60s http://ggordon528.tripod.com/shop/cpe/clutchflite.html

Isn't the PDK an automatic with a clutch same with Ferrari, the new Stingray and Hellcat? I always wondered if a PDK could be put into a 986.

Quotes source post: 444140

Most likely, if the computer was connected into the 986 correctly. The double-clutch transmissions are pretty fantastic.

Quotes source post: 444140

No, true "sequential manual gearboxes" (SMG) like the PDK or Ferrari use are actually a manual gear box that is shifted by a computer and uses dual wet clutches. GM and Chrysler still use an automatic transmission with a torque converter. As for adding a PDK to a 986, with enough time, welding equipment, and money; anything is possible.

Quotes source post: 444132

God, I haven't seen an Art Carr Clutch Flite in years!

Quotes source post: 444181

But it's still an automatic trans as it shifts for you with a clutch. Porsche Cayman - Porsche Doppelkupplung (PDK) - Porsche North America "Porsche Doppelkupplung (PDK) Of course, you could let us take care of the gearshift strategy so that you can devote all your attention to your cornering strategy, with the optional 7-speed Porsche Doppelkupplung (PDK) featuring both manual and automatic modes. PDK offers extremely fast gear changes with no interruption in the flow of power, improved acceleration over the manual transmission , very short response times, reduced fuel consumption and a distinct increase in comfort." You need to look into the Stingray and Hellcat some more, you're a little behind the time on those. New 8-Speed Enables Quicker, More Efficient Corvette "DETROIT – The all-new, GM-developed Hydra-Matic 8L90 paddle-shift eight-speed automatic transmission offered in the 2015 Corvette Stingray and Z06 enhances performance and efficiency, while delivering exceptional refinement and world-class shift responsiveness that rivals the world’s best dual-clutch transmissions." Dodge - Build & Price - TorqueFlite® Eight-Speed Automatic Transmission 2.62 Rear Axle Ratio A numerically lower axle ratio results in lower engine rpm and better fuel economy. A numerically higher ratio improves acceleration, climbing grades, carrying loads or pulling a trailer. AutoStick® Automatic Transmission Leather-Wrapped Shift Knob Remote Start System Check state and local laws regarding use of remote start systems. Steering Wheel Paddle Shifters Tip Start

Quotes source post: 444189

Yes basically automatic transmissions, more so with the Dodge and gm trans as they use a traditional torque converter, planetary gears, and basically give the user more control over the shifting. The Porsche PDK is less traditional and uses a nontraditional way of shifting the gears with a wet clutch. The BMW SMG is essentially a manual transmission with a hydraulic lever actually pushing a clutch arm and servos changing gears.... its a beautiful sound to hear a SMG up shift and down shift esp with a aftermarket exhaust. The computer actually raises and lowers the engine speed to match each gear shift, so with each downshift comes a blip of the throttle. You also have to put the trans in gear and/or neutral with the parking brake when parking the car, otherwise risk the car rolling like a manual trans The SMG trans has a typical clutch that wears like a normal clutch (if 40-60k miles can be considered normal) that needs to be replaced but no clutch pedal like a manual trans car. In none of these transmissions is there a clutch pedal though.

Quotes source post: 444189

It is more than a matter of semantics, if you saw the Vette or Doge trans out of the car, they have a torque converter, use pumps to generate pressure, planetary sets, sprags, pawls, and all the other stuff found in all automatic transmissions. If you saw the PDK out of a Porsche, it is not similar to the current seven speed manual, it is the seven speed manual , complete with gears, synchro rings and everything else you would find in a manual gear box, the big difference is that it uses a dual (one of even gears, one for odd) wet clutch system, and everything is controlled by computers, right down to "blipping" the throttle during down shifts.

I vote for this retrofit. Technology - Automotive Engineer

Quotes source post: 444217

I wonder how long the Porsche clutches last and if they are replaceable like a torque converter or where the clutch and clutch plates are changed like a automatic

Quotes source post: 444228

Being "wet", they should last a long time, particularly as the computer prevents any abuse and steps in if you get out of control. Interestingly, Porsche parts does not even list the clutch pack as a separate component part, so it may only be available as part of a factory reman trans.

That's a scary thought. Mr. Brown the your clutch is worn out.... that'll be $13,537 for the part and another 2300 for labor. But for your inconvenience we will provide a loaner car for the first two day we have it. Of course afterwards you will have to pay for the rental or use another form of transportation....

Quotes source post: 444242

Don't laugh; when the PDK cars warranty runs out, that is pretty much what they face if the PDK goes south as very few parts are available, there is no info on how to repair them, and a reman costs more like $17K (just for the unit in a crate).

Quotes source post: 444217

No, the Vette and the Hellcat do not have a torque converter. Did you bother to read the links I posted? From the Corvette link and the Hellcat gets this transmission ZF 8HP transmission - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia They are all automatic transmissions as they shift the gears for you. Porsche, Ferrari, Stingray, Hellcat, BMW, Lambo, Nissan GTR all of them are automatics using a clutch system.

Quotes source post: 444247

Sorry, but perhaps you need to re read them, from the Corvette article: "Unique clutch and torque converter specifications matched to the torque capacity of the Stingray’s LT1 6.2L naturally aspirated engine and the Z06’s LT4 supercharged engine distinguish the applications for the different Corvette models." And in the Doge article the transmission, with a torque converter clearly visible, as it is in the photo above. They are both conventional automatic transmissions, not an SMG like the PDK.

Yep you can plainly see it is a auto trans, only difference is heavier duty, and computer controlled, allowing buttons for shifting.

Quotes source post: 444254

It's not the torque converter of the old days and a clutch shifts the gears on the Vette. This Is How An Automatic Transmission Works The picture of the trans for the Hellcat I used the wrong picture. The hellcat gets the wet multiplate clutch.