fullymatted.
Back to search
Rennlist

Another 996 down

Add to repair workspace
Open repair workspace
Original source
140 captured repliesDiscussion pagination complete · Source accounts, not a confirmed diagnosis
THIS DISCUSSION / SOURCE-DERIVED OVERVIEW

Discussion summary

YOUR RESEARCHAnother 996 down

Reported or suspected cause

extended full throttle running you do

Reported cause

No successful repair reported for this finding.

1
Identified cause
0
Suspected cause
0
Reported fixes
Read evidence and context

Explicit resolution reports before identified causes, performed actions and suggestions. Within each level, matching component labels precede direct query mentions and inherited thread context; successful versus unsuccessful discussion counts, owner confirmations and independent discussion support determine order. This is not a probability of success.

Discussions that report identifying a cause
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Reported cause

The point of all this is, I relayed all to Jake and his opinion was it was the extended full throttle running you do on a roval like Daytona that puts the unusual stress on the engine which likely led to the failures.

Another 996 down
Frequently discussed work

Check acct)

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

I just don't have it in me (or in my checking acct) to pony up ANOTHER five digit payment to keep a $25k car on the road.

Another 996 down
Read full discussion summary

Leading evidence: 'extended full throttle running you do' (1 discussions report identifying this cause; no attributable repair resolution). Across 1 matching discussions, the most frequently mentioned possible cause is 'extended full throttle running you do' (1 discussions; 1 report identifying it and 0 suggest it). The most frequently discussed action is 'Check acct)' (1 discussions). For that action, 0 discussions report a resolution and 0 report an unsuccessful attempt. No action has an explicit, attributable resolution report under the current rules. These are forum reports and suggestions, not a confirmed diagnosis.

Source reports, not a diagnosis or a success probability. Counts refer to discussions and can overlap.

Read captured replies

1 matching discussions · 140 captured posts examined · 0 partial discussions

Compare 4 other evidence results

ims - i'm not a mechanic)

Reported cause

No successful repair reported for this finding.

1
Identified cause
0
Suspected cause
0
Reported fixes
Read evidence and context

Explicit resolution reports before identified causes, performed actions and suggestions. Within each level, matching component labels precede direct query mentions and inherited thread context; successful versus unsuccessful discussion counts, owner confirmations and independent discussion support determine order. This is not a probability of success.

Discussions that report identifying a cause
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Reported cause

His 2002 Boxster S had what the mechanic said was an IMS bearing let go and cause the dreaded catastrophic motor failure while driving on the highway (please save all the how did the mechanic know it was the IMS - I'm not a mechanic).

Another 996 down

Install very good reason

Performed · outcome unconfirmed

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context

Explicit resolution reports before identified causes, performed actions and suggestions. Within each level, matching component labels precede direct query mentions and inherited thread context; successful versus unsuccessful discussion counts, owner confirmations and independent discussion support determine order. This is not a probability of success.

Discussions that performed work without a confirmed outcome
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Performed · outcome unconfirmed

You won't see cars for sale with our engines installed for very good reason.

Another 996 down

Repair here is the note

Performed · outcome unconfirmed

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context

Explicit resolution reports before identified causes, performed actions and suggestions. Within each level, matching component labels precede direct query mentions and inherited thread context; successful versus unsuccessful discussion counts, owner confirmations and independent discussion support determine order. This is not a probability of success.

Discussions that performed work without a confirmed outcome
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Performed · outcome unconfirmed

Here is the note that the owner of that car submitted to us after his vehicle was repaired.

Another 996 down

Replace anyhow and my local dealer had the *****

Performed · outcome unconfirmed

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context

Explicit resolution reports before identified causes, performed actions and suggestions. Within each level, matching component labels precede direct query mentions and inherited thread context; successful versus unsuccessful discussion counts, owner confirmations and independent discussion support determine order. This is not a probability of success.

Discussions that performed work without a confirmed outcome
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Performed · outcome unconfirmed · Original poster

I needed to have my RMS replaced anyhow and my local dealer had the ***** to quote me 7k for RMS and two cam cover seals.

Another 996 down
Frequently discussed actions (10)

These are separate views of the same evidence. Frequency alone does not establish a fix, and these counts must not be added together.

Check acct)

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

I just don't have it in me (or in my checking acct) to pony up ANOTHER five digit payment to keep a $25k car on the road.

Another 996 down

Clean higher mileage car

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

Gator is a good guy with a super clean higher mileage car.

Another 996 down

Clean work area, and time, is all you need

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

Service manuals, proper tools, clean work area, and time, is all you need.

Another 996 down

Install very good reason

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that performed work without a confirmed outcome
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Performed · outcome unconfirmed

You won't see cars for sale with our engines installed for very good reason.

Another 996 down

Recommend him, even though i live in ga ans had

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

I highly recommend him, even though I live in GA ans had to ship the motor across the country.

Another 996 down

Recommend performing an ims'ectomy in the vancouver/vanc

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

Any shop you would recommend performing an IMS'ectomy in the Vancouver/Vanc.

Another 996 down

Recommend vision motorsports in laguna hills

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

I have some good racer friends in Southern California who recommended Vision Motorsports in Laguna Hills.

Another 996 down

Repair /replacements as needed

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

Jake, from the support you receive here on RL, you clearly know what you are talking about when it comes to the failures on the 996 and the repair/replacements as needed.

Another 996 down

Repair but

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

I spoke at length with him concerning repair but with over 100k miles and a questionable service life after the repair the economics support that option less.

Another 996 down

Repair economics support

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Reported fixes
0
Unsuccessful attempts
1
Discussions
Read evidence and context
Discussions that contain suggestions
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suggestion

I spoke at length with him concerning repair but with over 100k miles and a questionable service life after the repair the economics support that option less.

Another 996 down
Reported and suspected causes (3)

These are separate views of the same evidence. Frequency alone does not establish a fix, and these counts must not be added together.

extended full throttle running you do

No successful repair reported for this finding.

1
Identified cause
0
Suspected cause
0
Reported fixes
Read evidence and context
Discussions that report identifying a cause
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Reported cause

The point of all this is, I relayed all to Jake and his opinion was it was the extended full throttle running you do on a roval like Daytona that puts the unusual stress on the engine which likely led to the failures.

Another 996 down

ims - i'm not a mechanic)

No successful repair reported for this finding.

1
Identified cause
0
Suspected cause
0
Reported fixes
Read evidence and context
Discussions that report identifying a cause
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Reported cause

His 2002 Boxster S had what the mechanic said was an IMS bearing let go and cause the dreaded catastrophic motor failure while driving on the highway (please save all the how did the mechanic know it was the IMS - I'm not a mechanic).

Another 996 down

same as everyone else here

No successful repair reported for this finding.

0
Identified cause
1
Suspected cause
0
Reported fixes
Read evidence and context
Discussions that suspect a cause
1

0 original-poster resolution reports. Counts can overlap; they are not unique people or a success rate.

0 discussions have direct query context; 0 report a fix in that context. Other evidence may inherit the discussion’s subject.

Suspected cause

I am likely the same as everyone else here.

Another 996 down
Coverage and how to read this overview

Counts describe captured discussions, not unique people or a diagnosis. Author identities are not reliably stored. Exact duplicate evidence is counted once across matching discussions; one discussion counts at most once per action/state. Multiple repairs reported together remain a combination. Suggestions and failed attempts do not establish a fix. Matches cover whole discussions and can include related faults, model variants and incomplete threads.

140 eligible posts · 0 unverified posts · 1 discussions match the subject in their title or opening post.

  • Rennlist: 1 discussions

0 evidence records excluded for query context · 0 excluded by outcome qualification · 0 adjusted by outcome qualification.

3 acknowledgements have no verified action link; they do not establish a repair result.

Outcome without a verified action link

I then drove the car 400 miles to ensure the issue was resolved and then we shipped it home to Pennsylvania.

No unique explicit quoted action; no causal link assigned

Generation: 20261026T190023Z · outcome-qualification-6. Deterministic extraction; no AI model inference. How we use sources

POST 1 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Well, it happened to me last night. Driving home from the gym, 35 mph and whammo, total loss of power. There was no eerie sounds or warnings. No CEL and no codes with my OBD reader (it was worth a shot). I coasted into a parking lot and sulked. I was hoping it was an electrical issue and went to bed with that dream. First thing in the morning, i had the car towed home. I tried turning the crank and it didnt budge one bit. Now I realize that I am in deep poop. I wisely called Jake Raby at Flat 6 Innovations. First off, Jake and Dean are true gentlemen and I want to thank them for taking the time to speak with me. Poor Jake's phone was ringing off the hook behind him. He walked me through the options and I am waiting go the wife to get home and discuss what to do. I have no clue what the damage is but at the minimum it sounds like a rebuild. My nearest Porsche Indy is 1.5 hours away so I just brought it home. Otherwise I would be paying a hefty tow bill and many hundreds of dollars for them to peer inside and confirm that I am screwed. Car is a 2000 C2 with 115,000 miles. She has performed flawlessly in the 1.5 I have owned it. All maintenance was up to date. So, I have to figure out whether to sell as a roller or go with Jakes engine. Right now I am still in a fog. This is like losing a child for me since I don't have kids. Thanks for letting me vent. He she was on Saturday morning headed to Daytona. And the second pic is Wednesday morning 😣

POST 2Original post

Ed, So sorry about your engine. Don't be too quick to sell it as a roller. Do the math first. Jake made you an excellent offer for the replacement. And if you sell it, what would your really want? I saw the look on your face when you were next to me on the way down to Daytona, and then the perma-smile in my mirror while we were lapping at the track. Take three real deep breaths. Then talk to your bride. She is a clear thinker.

POST 3Original post

Awe man sorry to hear about this. My motor died on me last year as well. Many options out there tho as im sure you know. Good luck getting her back on the road.

POST 4Original post

Sorry to hear about the engine and best of luck in getting it sorted out. What was the mode of failure? Also, if this happened after lapping Daytona, was oil starvation the problem? I ask because I too have considered doing Daytona with my 996 but decided against it due to the high banking and high G loads which could contribute to oil starvation on the M96. Not to mention the threat of blown rear tires, etc. due to the high banking.

POST 5Original post

DC, The laps we did Saturday at Daytona were touring laps , down on the apron only. No banking. Below 75 mph. Oil starvation was not the cause. In fact, Ed drove over 100 miles home on Saturday, and had been home several days since that event, and drove his car every day to work before the problem occurred. Not sure of the exact diagnosis, yet, but the crankshaft is truly frozen. However, you are absolutely correct regarding the issues to consider should you decide to do a DE or Club Race at Daytona. There was a ton of mechanical and physical carnage to the DE and Club Racer cars this past weekend there. No physical injuries to the drivers thankfully. LOTS of crumpled sheet metal, and broken engines and suspensions. Mostly folks whose ego's outpaced their skill (both on the track and in the garage). Neither Ed nor I were entered in the DE or Club Race. We were the lead and pack pace cars for 84 street stock Porsches that signed up for "baby laps" around the full road course circuit. They paid $10 for the 3 laps. 100% of the money was donated to The Wounded Warrior Project. EVERYBODY said it was great and want to do it again next year. Even had one gentleman who arrived too late to do the laps but still gave us $10 for Wounded Warrior Project.

POST 6Original post

Have Jake do a 3.6 build. You won't regret it. Plus, she's too pretty to give up on...

POST 7Original post

Ed, Sorry to hear this happened! I was there with you guys too and the laps were a blast. Nothing we did during those laps could have contributed in any way to the engine issues. I'd be interested to hear what direction you decide to go. Everything I've read seems to indicate Jake is the way to go. You're car looks just too pretty to part out as a roller.

POST 8Original post

Sorry to hear about your misfortune. What a great-looking car! It sounds as though you have a tough decision ahead- best of luck with your choice.

POST 9Original post

Used motor with new IMSB would make sense financially

POST 10Original post

Quotes source post: 9908530

From an unemotional point of view, this makes total sense. Also, a Porsche or Raby motor will cost you $20-30K,and you can get a low mileage 2000 all day for that money. So another option is just to sell it as a roller for $3k and buy another.

POST 11Original post

Sorry to hear about this. I think it would have been easier for me to make up a story about some illegitimate child that I had been hiding all of these years then tell my wife that the 996 need a new/rebuilt engine... In then end I consider myself lucky. I'd been driving pretty quickly though some twisties only 20 minutes prior. Had the engine cut out mid-turn I would have been without power steering, assisted brakes, etc... Who knows what could have happened. In the end at least you were at a safe point for the failure to occur. Take care, Chris

POST 12Original post

Quotes source post: 9908553

$3K?!?!? and how exactly did you come up with this number?

POST 14 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Thanks to everyone for the support. Chris, it was great talking with you today. I just had a meeting with my financial advisor/attorney (wife) and she agrees with my assessment that a motor from Jake is the best option. So, I am in contact with Flat 6 and getting the wheels in motion. Wife and I need to work out the financials (scary part) but hopefully my ole 996 will be on the road in a few months. Thanks again to my fellow Rennlisters. Unless you have been where I am, it is hard to describe how emotional a blown motor is. Yes, it's just a car but I think we Porsche owners look at it a bit differently.

POST 16Original post

"35 mph and whammo, total loss of power. There was no eerie sounds or warnings. No CEL and no codes with my OBD reader" "I have no clue what the damage is but at the minimum it sounds like a rebuild." sorry for whats happened stupid question coming: how did you go from your first sentence to the second sentence? did you take it into a shop and have it diagnosed? just curious

POST 17 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Quotes source post: 9908980

Fair question. I had emailed Jake with my symptoms, hoping it was a blown fuse. HA! Anyhow, he recommended that I try and turn the crank manually. I used a 24mm socket on the crank pulley and tried to turn it. A healthy engine should turn without much effort. Mine didn't budge, no matter how much force I put into it. So, if the crank is frozen, something catastrophic went on inside. At a minimum it would beca total tear down, inspection and god knows what else. I could do a rebuild with an Indy locally or just go with one already done by Jake, drop it in and be on the road in a few weeks with peace of mind.

POST 18Original post

With the spark plugs in, it takes effort to turn the engine by hand. Did just that last week. But if the engine is siezed up, try turning it over with the starter. If that doesn't do it, you have a locked up engine. As for being able to rebuild it, well thay all depends what kind of damage there is. Also, keep in mind that not evergthing can be rebuilt.

POST 19Original post

Gator996, I know that punch in the gut feeling too well. The feeling comes back strongly every time I read about someone else experiencing it with their car. Based on my personal rebuild experience, your decision to use Jake and his guy's expertise to get you back on the road is a very sound one. He did mine about a year ago and I am beyond satisfied. I didn't go to him initially and paid a heavy price for trying to save a few thousand dollars. I visited the F6I skunkworks after my unsuccessful first attempt to have it rebuilt. I had spoken to Jake few times prior to going down the wrong path but wanted to see the operation myself prior to plunking down the big bucks. I left there very impressed with the people and facilities but even more impressed with the scope of the F6I rebuild. The depth of that scope was not apparent to me from reading the website or speaking to him on the phone. I believe you will be very pleased once it is delivered to you with what will essentially be a new, and better constructed engine. Quick note on Daytona and my and a buddy's M96 motors. We were both there for a PBOC event in October or November the year before it was closed to DE events for re-paving. My 996 was totally stock at the time except for Pagid Orange pads and Sport Cups. By afternoon I was lightly feathering the throttle to keep it at 7k in 5th gear exiting NASCAR 2 and thru the tri-oval and on the back straight heading towards the Bus Stop. I wasn't confident enough at that speed to take one hand off the wheel to shift into 6th. It was quite a thrill and the car was quite stable except for the slightest sensation of front end lift. That was with the body totally stock as well. I signed up for two days but in the race that same afternoon, a Scuderia version Ferrari Challange race car hada rear tire let go at over 180 on the exit to NASCAR 2. His in car video is on you tube he spun 8 - 10 times down the front straight and fortunately didn't hit anything. That took the starch out of me and i drove home the next morning on my used PSC tires. The point of all of thus is my buddy and I suffered engine failures some months later. His 2002 Boxster S had what the mechanic said was an IMS bearing let go and cause the dreaded catastrophic motor failure while driving on the highway (please save all the how did the mechanic know it was the IMS - I'm not a mechanic). Mine spun a bearing causing the scavenger pump to give up and damage the valves serving cylinder 5. I was at HMS for my first DE after Daytona. I drove it the 70 miles to my home (really, freaking dumb, right?) before having it flatbedded to the wrong rebuild shop. The point of all this is, I relayed all to Jake and his opinion was it was the extended full throttle running you do on a roval like Daytona that puts the unusual stress on the engine which likely led to the failures. I'd talk to him about if you run Daytona regularly. Best of luck - you will soon be falling even deeper in love with your baby. And your wife too for offering such great advice!

POST 20Original post

If it happened to me I'd make the same decision you made - good call IMO!!

POST 21Original post

Please substitute NASCAR 4 for all NASCAR 2 references in my earlier reply to Gator996. The Editor

POST 22Original post

You are driving along normally and the engine cuts out and all of a sudden you need a new engine???????????????????... I think I need to stop this message right there before I really upset someone. oh is it a mazda you are driving.. sorry...

POST 23Original post

Gator, You need to understand what this engine is that I have offered you. It is not rebuilt and has not been reconstructed. This engine is something that we haven't had in over a year because we can't find acceptable donors to become our CPO engines. We have disassembled the engine completely and added the list of items to it that I emailed to you along with the IMSB, water pump, AOS, RMS and etc. lots of the posters here don't know that we offer anything other than our full blown reconstructions like fasteddie and 996c2 have purchased and that's not the case with your situation. BTW 996c2 is the guy that wrote the testimonial that I sent you the link to. Ask him how cost effective a cheap engine with a written warranty actually is. I am sure the pain is still quite fresh in his memory even after over a year has passed. It's seldom that we can offer any repair solution is only a month and for less than 18k, but honestly I am not positive that this engine is for you, because I believe you have an over expectation for it and because you expect a warranty which is something we only extend if an engine sees ALL of our reconstruction points and that's what starts at 18k today. I refuse to guarantee anything produced by any other.. That includes Porsche. Unless our hands and minds developed, applied and tested the entire arrangement we offer it with an up front understanding that the engine family has 23 modes of documented failure and we have only addressed 3 of them with our lower cost alternative in the CPO offering. Anything that we reconstruct sees 12 months unlimited mileage warranty with no fine print involved. These days the truth is hard to find and direct communication is harder to find. We offer both.

POST 24Original post

Gator, sorry for your car but maybe you could go into it yourself? Its not a Chevy SB V8 but its not a Space Shuttle either. Service manuals, proper tools, clean work area, and time, is all you need. Any machine work needed you can send out the parts. Maybe its a spun main bearing? Other option is the salvage auctions. Many wrecked 996's out there with used engines. Best of luck.

POST 25Original post

sorry for your loss but extremely jealous of your new engine!

POST 26Original post

Have it checked out locally before you throw in the towel.

POST 27Original post

Quotes source post: 9909174

[Image-only post; no author-written text. Original image references:] https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/confused.gif

POST 28Original post

$18K and no warranty. A lot of work can be done for 18000. Since your mechanical knowldge is very limited. Spend a couple hours of labour and get a proper diagnosis. Think of it as a PPI for a repair. Engines can be repaired and not always just rebuilt. My latest project is a '99 996 that had bent valves. I'm in the home stretch of finishing fixing it and the total bill, not includimg my labour, is well under $2000.

POST 29Original post

You have misunderstood the cost of this CPO engine. It is not 18k, that's what my full reconstructions cost. The CPO engine is roughly 1/2 that cost if you consider that the installed cost including all fluids and lubricants for 12.5k. I spoke at length with him concerning repair but with over 100k miles and a questionable service life after the repair the economics support that option less. We repair engines with big problems all the time and take pride in saving engines but the return on investment has to be there before I offer that option. Considering the engine is locked up it probably needs a crank. Try to find a crank today, used ones are going for 2k if you can even find one. Unlike other engines no under or oversize bearings are available so restoration through regrinding is not an option. We have developed bearings and should have them available to the public in the next 18 months.

POST 30 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

The CPO Jake has makes perfect sense. Firstly, I would not have a rebuild on my motor done by anyone else but Flat 6. But like Jake stated above, it doesn't make financial sense to spend that kind of money for a car of my mileage and year. With the CPO engine, I am still very close to market price for what I am into this car for. I will have full faith knowing that the IMS, RMS, etc has already been taken care of. Could I have mine rebuilt locally? Sure. Would I have full confidence in the build? Probably not. A 18+ grand rebuild for a car worth in the very low 20's just doesnt work for me. If I was really married to this car or it was something I just couldnt live without then maybe I would do it. But, it is a car that I enjoy and can now have some peace of mind and confidence in its engine. I know the CPO engine is not a rebuild but, even a rebuild can blow up in my face at some point. Mechanical things are mechanical things. So, I have full confidence in Flat 6 and there expertise and know that they would not steer me in the wrong direction just to make a buck. Hell, Jake is trying to talk me out of this thing now. Not gonna happen. I will be making the arrangements this morning with him and hopefully talking with a shipper in the near future.

POST 31Original post

Wondering, would the Guardian have detected the pre catastrophic event and then possibly saved the engine or at least minimize the damage ?

POST 32Original post

Sorry to hear your misfortune......please keep us posted on the replacement process and when you have your foot back into it....

POST 33Original post

The CPO is the cheapest route and you'll be back driving but there is no assurance that the engine won't have the same thing happen to it later on. There all just ticking time bombs, not even the M96's in the 997 are immune. My thinking is that for 6 k more you'll get a engine that will last much longer, has better cooling, has a triple row IMS and shaft retrofit and the displacement increase guarantees more hp. All that for only 5-6k more. Whats the difference on a 5-6k more loan at the end of the day, probably a coffee a day?

POST 34Original post

Gator, I am in the lab today profiling camshafts, so I'll call you on my way home this evening. I am not trying to talk you out of the engine; I am trying to ensure that you understand exactly what is being purchased and that your expectation level is realistic for it. I have learned that hasty decisions account for most disappointment and over-expectation in this world; so slow down and consider the choices wisely. We take pride in working with each broken car like it was our own and thats been key to the success of my entire engine program. We are very careful when selling any product and service that features a lower price than our standard cost of admission because thats a breeding ground for issues. Each engine that leaves these doors has the possibility of becoming a much greater liability than anything else. All it takes is one. That mindset is shared by many, many others that have engine failures that most of you here would believe. We are currently booked solid through June of next year for full reconstructions with cars here from 18 states currently and 4 more inbound. The CPO engine is something I've had for 2-3 months after taking the initiative to prepare it for someone like Gator who didn't wish to spend 18K, over a dozen people so far that could have afforded it chose not to purchase it and to wait their turn for a full reconstruction. Of all those cars that are seeing the fully reconstructed engines only two of them are actually worth more than the 18.5K engine cost. Those people love their cars, which is the requirement for spending more on the engine than the car is worth. Nothing new there, years ago we were creating 10,000.00 engines for 914s that weren't worth 4K bucks.

POST 35 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

We are all good Jake. Lots of emotion the past two days. A good nights sleep and a clear head today only reaffirms what the best course of action is for my particular car. Give me a shout tonight and thanks for your patience!

POST 36Original post

As another wise poster on this forum said, "Hey, it's only money. You'll always make more." Sad to hear about your loss, but happy to hear that there's a path forward.

POST 37Original post

Hope it all works out financially, seems you will be getting a better motor in the end. I remember seeing a video - a Porsche 993 infomercial. They say they ran the 993's all day, at red-line, to test the motors. Wonder if they did that for our cars??

POST 38Original post

Im going to have to agree with jumper. Since the car needs a motor why not throw a bored out 3.6 or 3.8 in there with forged pistons, nikasil cylinders and a triple row bearing. This is the course I took and now my car is pushing 300 tq rear wheels. I have about 7000 street and track miles on my rebuild and car is running like a champ. No more pointbys for 996 GT3s

POST 39Original post

Quotes source post: 9911229

And how much did that cost?

POST 40Original post

Quotes source post: 9911623

The arm he used to use for point by's :-) m

POST 41Original post

Quotes source post: 9911623

Doesn't matter what it cost. If you assume that the car is worth $20,000 in good running condition, and the completely rebuilt engine installed is $20,000 more, you are still in for $20-30,000 LESS than it would take to get into a 2009 Carrera 2 (997.2) or newer, in order to completely not have the problem, and get a remaining year of warranty. And not one in a thousand people knows the difference between any year 911. If it is shiny they think it is brand new. Period. If your gonna drive it a lot, keep what you have and deal with the issues as they arise. If you are going to try to make a "business case" for owning a 996 or any other Porsche, then you should have bought a Camry. And NEVER buy a boat! LOL!

POST 42Original post

Quotes source post: 9911944

That's nice but I wasn't asking you.

POST 43Original post

My 18k engine takes a 3.4 to a 3.6 or a 3.6 to a 3.8 as standard practice. With LN Engineering we were the first in this country to offer a big bore engine and to date it's still the most developed product available. I just returned from a 6,788 mile trip testing our Generation 3 engine all te way to Canada and back equipped with the IMS Solution. The Gen3 technology allows a Nikisil bore and engine combination that suppers a 3.9 liter engine from the 3.4 base engine or 4.2 liters from the 3.6 and 3.8 liter foundations. This is our combo of internals from scratch. The biggest hurdle in this development hasn't been just making the engine big but more importantly maintaining a broad power band which has taken exceptional development in regard to cylinder head and intake modifications. Building an engine this big, keeping it street able enough to support daily driving but also rev 8k RPM is a huge undertaking. Gen3 engines are being released after the new year:-) Anyway, Gator went for the engine and I wouldn't allow him to make a hasty decision. We'll be posting the process on our Facebook page at www.facebook.com/fixabrokensix He wanted the engine a lot more than I wanted to sell it to him, which seems to blow people's minds on a routine basis :-) Hell, I got my best paycheck possible today when we saved an engine that was deemed a total loss by a Porsche dealership. In less than 4 hours we saved someone well over 14k bucks and had the car back on the road again. Nothing is better than that at my level. Nothing.

POST 44Original post

Quotes source post: 9911944

Funny thing is that a nicely decked out Camry or Accord will cost more then an engine rebuild and at the end of the day your driving a POS.

POST 47 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

I did decide to go with the CPO engine but the decision was strictly from a financial standpoint. I do plan to upgrade to a 997 in the near future. I bought this car way under market value when prices bottomed out. Now, I know I will take a loss on resale like most of us will. Hell, its a 12 year old car. But, with the $12.5K motor investment, I am now more in line of what the car should have sold for, or close, when I bought it, ie, mid 20's. So, investing 18k+ just did not make sound financial sense at this point if I am not going to keep it for another two or three years. I can stand to lose a few thousand or several thousand if sold as a roller. There is some emotional attachment to the car but not enough to go nuts with upgrades. This is my third Porsche (928,944,996) so it seems I am always moving to the next step every few years. There is the possibility that I may, at some point, gut it for a full time track car or purchase a prepared one. I would love nothing more than a full rebuild from Jake, believe me. The biggest consideration in my life is my wife. She has tons of input into my decisions since they affect her as well. Squeezing 12 plus thousand out of our asses was not a joy in this economy but had to be done. I will have a car I can enjoy for quite some time and have peace of mind that Jake inspected it (NOT REBUILT IT), the RMS and IMS is taken care of etc. Can this motor crap out on the way home? Sure. Can one of his rebuilds do the same? Sure. They are mechanical bits and things happen. But, I am not worried about it. All I want to do now is get the car up there, get it back and start enjoying my PCA outings again. Thanks to everyone who has offered advice, especially Jake Raby. He is a true gentleman and runs a first class operation. Like I said in some previous entries, unless you have been in my position, it is hard to fully grasp how stressful it really is. I will update the post as things move along.

POST 48Original post

Quotes source post: 9912671

Uh, if jake's rebuild bit the dust on the way home (highly unlikely), he's going to make it right. Paying another $6k makes sense to me IMO. Good Luck.

POST 49 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Quotes source posts: 9912779, 9912671

Believe me, I would like nothing more than to do that. If my wife wasn't gearing up for a political campaign next year I would. She is my priority as are our finances. I am completely comfortable with the CPO engine an plan on enjoying the **** out of my car as long as I can.

POST 50Original post

Quotes source post: 9912779

I don't see at all how $18k motor in $20K car would make sense.

POST 51Original post

We do the right thing even when no one is looking.. As long as the purchaser remains tactful, respectful and understanding we will bend over backward to extend the same service to them that we'd expect if the roles were reversed. I can count how many "issues" we have had since 1992 on one hand, which is quite amazing. Of those engines two people turned into jackasses and neither of them received any help; the others walked away with fully repaired engines and no balance due at the end of the day. I have learned how to watch for red flags and certain terms and questions are a dead giveaway in regard to the caliber of person we are dealing with. Because of that more than 1/4 of the work that finds us is accepted into the program and thats about the only way we can maintain our reputation. Some people have unreasonable expectations of both man and machine. Its important that we ensure those people seek out the competition for their services, because that generally hurts the competition more than it helps them. One reason why we ship cars from all over North America to our facility and extend free removal and replacement of any reconstructed engine for free as an incentive for the cars to be shipped to us is so we can test them extensively on the road and on the chassis dyno. I typically drive any engine that we build 200 miles so we can carry out the first service, bore scope the cylinders, carry out lak down and compression tests and gather an oil sample. This way we treat the engine like it is guilty and it has to prove it's innocence before we ship the car home. This avoids occurrences of petty CEL illuminations, oil leaks, mechanical noises and other gripes that are always a reality after carrying out extensive repairs on any vehicle/ engine. In the time we have worked with the M96 engine we have had to "warranty" one engine, which I feel is too many. To restore the engine we had to ship the car from Pennsylvania to Ga, completely disassemble the engine, replace many components and then reinstall it back into the vehicle. I then drove the car 400 miles to ensure the issue was resolved and then we shipped it home to Pennsylvania. Shipping cost us 1100 bucks round trip, the engine work cost us 13,000.00 and the customer didn't pay a singe dime. He was respectful, understanding and gracious and never found an attitude, pissed, moaned or complained. Because of that we did the right thing with no hassles and we exceeded his expectations for the whole project and the repair. The reality is anything thats mechanical can fail at any point and for absolutely no reason, people who don't understand that haven't lived a life surrounded by machines. Here is the note that the owner of that car submitted to us after his vehicle was repaired. Ed seems to be a great guy with a real expectation of what this engine is. We took a few days to exchange information and now I feel that this engine will meet his expectations. It only makes sense if the vehicle owner wishes to keep it forever. You won't see cars for sale with our engines installed for very good reason. More people go the 18K route than anyone here would imagine, in fact we have 16 engines backlogged at the present. A 10K engine in a 4K 914 also doesn't make sense, but we were doing that in the mid 1990s.

POST 52 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Well said Jake. My decision to choose Flat 6 was not done in haste. My research had been underway for quite some time even before I had a motor issue. I cannot express to everyone here of how your professionalism and more importantly, your knowledge, has helped through my greiving process. You and Dean have been a breath of fresh air and I cant thank you enough. I am sure there are some great Porsche indy's near me but I know I made the right decision to call Flat 6 first and skip the runaround and unknowns. Dean just called a few minutes ago and a shipper will be here Monday to haul my 995.5 to you to once again make it a 996. We plan to drive up to Helen when its done and stretch her legs down I-75 for the ride home...smiling all the way. Thanks again Jake!!

POST 53Original post

Quotes source post: 9912203

I think it moved, Jerry!

POST 54Original post

I am sorry to hear about this. Reminds me of the day my car died. Sucks!!!

POST 55 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Quotes source post: 9913020

As a Seinfeld afficiando, thanks for that. I needed a good chuckle today! On another note of good news; Dean at Flat 6 arranged a shipper for me. We spec'd an open trailer since it really doesnt matter at this point if the car gets dirty. I was figuring it might take a week or two to get my car picked up. With all of the traffic of snowbirds heading south, a transport was available this Monday! The greater news is that they are getting me an enclosed transport for the open trailer price. 300 bucks to ship this thing. Steal!! Another plus of working with Jake Raby is that he is able to get the customer the broker price on transport. That is a win for the customer and a customer service feather in the hat for Flat 6. These guys rock!

POST 56Original post

Quotes source post: 9912203

Will pricing and performance info be released prior to the actual engine release? Will FSI taking in customer's engine for the Gen3 update/upgrade or is it being offered as a turn-key arrangement?

POST 57Original post

We always build from the purchasers engine unless it is destroyed. That means we extract the engine and process it into a turnkey arrangement. This ensures that all responsibilities related to the engine and the application into the vehicle as well as testing is arrived out under our roof. I'll include pricing in our next newsletter, these engines start at 22k.

POST 58 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Sunday morning and the shipper just called. Car will be picked up Monday at 0900. Whoo hoo! It might be in your parking lot tomorrow Jake.

POST 59Original post

It sucks to HAVE to do it, but man why not mod up to 3.8 or drool 4.2L. If you have a hot rodder in you, spending $20k on a $20-35k car is normal, hell my 1990 mustang, worth maybe 5k with a stock motor i spent $20k on performance mods. People do it all the time, there are plenty of $80-100k mustangs out there. Here at least you are still driving a Porsche, and that means something. Heaven forbid if mine blows I would most certainly want a bigger, better motor not just a replacement otherwise it would feel like i spent all that cash just to have what i had before it blew.

POST 60Original post

Sorry to hear about the engine, but you made the right decision. You are going to be SOOOOO happy once you get it back, regardless of which displacement you pick.

POST 61Original post

Quotes source post: 9917233

Gator, I hope it waits till Tuesday.. We need to get a few out of here, we are so slammed that even 30,000 sq ft isn't enough space to keep all the cars inside.. Hell the 40k sq ft warehouse on the other side of town where we keep cars off site is almost full too! If all goes well you shoul have it back at the end f the month.. I don't think I have ever been able to tell someone that before...

POST 62Original post

Interesting Jake, really 2 weeks? That's amazing. Found out a way to speed up plating?? or are you doing cores? From the sound of your earlier post you are not prepping cores?

POST 63Original post

Quotes source post: 9917715

NO! The engine Gator has purchased Is a rarity, it's my CPO package and NOT a reconstruction that uses plated cylinders. If he chose the reconstructed, big bore engine he'd not be seeing his car till the week of July 4, 2013 and would spend 8-10k more $.

POST 64Original post

Oh ok, sorry I misread the thread... I was going to say that would be nothing short of a miracle.

POST 65 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

I will tell the driver to take the long way. Hell, he could drop it in downtown Helen. It's not like somebody can steal it.

POST 66Original post

We can make room for a couple of days. Have one headed back to Canada early in the week and several others almost done too.

POST 67 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

My car just arrived at Flat 6 about 20 minutes ago. The transporter had not even left yet when Jake got my car running!! He will be posting a video shortly. Stunned and thrilled to say the least. A lesser shop would have sold me a rebuild. I will give Jake the honor of telling the rest of the story.

POST 69Original post

This should be interesting, hope it bodes well for you. Have been following your story and posts, GL.

POST 70 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Quotes source post: 9922516

Thanks Steve. We are not out of the woods quite yet but things are definitely looking up.

POST 71Original post

Quotes source post: 9922513

Nope.. We stopped using them just after they moved your car. The owner was unable to meet our expectations, so after more than 100 moves we said goodbye to them. Instead we became our own shipping brokers and just allow the owners of the cars and the shipping company to take advantage of the lower rates. This way we have more control of the whole process and its cheaper and better for all involved. I am editing a video that explains Ed'd issue well.. Will post it in a few minutes.

POST 72Original post

That wasn't the return pump we saw on your FB page was it Jake?

POST 73Original post

Gator, good luck! Only you know what the right solution for you is, regardless of the many pundits here. I lost my motor back in April and felt the same shock and dismay. I opted to sooth the pain w/ a new baby, but still miss the old girl.

POST 74Original post

Does anyone else find it interesting that Jake and Gator are communicating via this forum? I'm thinking I would be calling, texting, emailing....

POST 75Original post

Quotes source post: 9922565

This is like a thriller novel......... can't wait for the video!

POST 76 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Jake and I are in contact several times a day via phone, email and text. We thought it might be good for other 'listers to walk along with a Porsche owner in distress and a guru mechanic. I know others have gone through a failure and surely others will in the future. Everyone will be as surprised as I was when Jake called this morning with the diagnosis.

POST 77Original post

Quotes source post: 9923081

Ed originally contacted me on my forums. He, myself and Dean have had a lot of communication; he is the one that decided to post this thread here. (I knew that some vendor hater would arrive in the thread at some point- let me guess, you think Gator is a shill and not even a real person? The conspiracy theorist here amaze me.) Here is a quick video I made of the car and the situation that I posted on our facebook page at this link: https://www.facebook.com/fixabrokensix We have to do more invasive evaluation prior to giving Gator his options for how to proceed with proactive procedures. This includes the compression checks, leak down tests, bore scope cylinder inspections, oil sump inspection and a dyno run to see how it rates power wise with all the other 996s in its same mileage point that we have worked with. If the engine has other issues its not worth updating the IMS and other items as part of a deluxe preventive package. At the same time there is no use to just swap this engine out and spend Gator's money on something that he doesn't really need. Gator will have a lot of choices and options now; previously he only had one. Gator is a good guy with a super clean higher mileage car. Keep up with our progress on our facebook page; now that the vendor haters have arrived its time that I leave this thread.

POST 79Original post

Quotes source post: 9923110

Not a vendor hater. Not a conspiracy theorist. Just thought it was interesting. Jake, from the support you receive here on RL, you clearly know what you are talking about when it comes to the failures on the 996 and the repair/replacements as needed. I also think you are excellent at marketing your company. Please take this as a compliment.

POST 80Original post

d a r n .....can't see....no facebook account

POST 81Original post

Wow! What a nice surprise. I hope all the other checks go well and Gator gets his ride back soon.

POST 82Original post

We don't market other than FB and the website.. No banner ads, no huge magazine ads, no sponsorships. Our works does all the marketing that we need to stay months backlogged year round. I used to like forum interchange, but not so much these days. People have changed.

POST 83Original post

Wow.. Its stuff like this were the internet does not come in handy for answers.. Fear mongers at work. Any other car has this issue, self destruction would never be the first thought before not even spending 5 min looking at the motor to see what indeed failed.

POST 84Original post

Quotes source post: 9923153

I don't do FB & I was able to watch it.....

POST 85Original post

Quotes source post: 9923163

Sorry Jake, I did not mean to offend. But just to see another side, in my simple observation, Gator's car siezed. He immediately thinks the engine is toast (because of all the IMS, etc threads on these sites). Immediately calls you. Ships the car. Finds out its just an ------- (don't want to spoil your video). All he had to do was take it to his shop. Maybe they would have found what you found. By marketing, I am actually talking about how you generally let little things slip in your posts, especially when talking about (and I am paraphrasing) how the non believers should see all the cars in your shop and then they would know how real these failures are....yet you have the time to surf RL like the rest of us. IMHO, I believe you are an excellent mechanic who knows how to promote his business. It certainly worked with Gator (who I am very happy for by the way). I am likely the same as everyone else here. We just hope we never need you.

POST 86Original post

I understand. As far as time to surf RL, I'll say this. My work doesn't occur during normal hours and I often will not be finished with my tasks until midnight, or I'll have my *** at the shop by 0500 other days (after an hour commute) to do what is required. There is no where within my facility that a computer isn't within 20' feet of where I'll be found at any time of the day. Doing what I do means that we have down time and I use that efficiently. Honestly today I should be down stairs tearing down a Cayenne R&D engine for our next stage of development; but I find myself assisting Dean with the management of cars at our facility from 18 states. Development work is my thing.

POST 87 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

I certainly see your points Gonzo and can't disagree. Did I panic when I couldn't turn the crank? Hell yes. We have all read the horror stories of IMS failure or other issues with the M96. So, I had a few choices. Take it to an indie and hope it was a simple issue. Worst case, it was toast and I would ship it to Jake anyhow. Lots of time and money wasted on the indie. Nobody but Flat 6 will rebuild my motor. I lucked out this time and its in the ideal place for some needed repairs. I needed to have my RMS replaced anyhow and my local dealer had the ***** to quote me 7k for RMS and two cam cover seals. Thanks but, no. For $300 in transport costs I can have not only the needed repairs done at a very fair hourly rate but also a dyno, bore scope etc. I would have paid $200 to have it towed to an indie since I live in the middle of nowhere. All in all, I win and Jake wins by forming a new customer relationship.

POST 88Original post

Quotes source post: 9923277

Is that $300.00 round trip or one way?

POST 89Original post

300.00 one way.. Thats a steal enclosed! We just shipped a 996 from Fresno Ca to our facility in Ga for 800.00 which is also a steal.. Both movers have 99% ratings on central dispatch. This situation with Gator is backward from what we normally experience. Typically the owner takes the car to an Indy shop that gets in way over their head after the car is taken apart..Then its shipped to us in a box and we have to deal with lost parts.

POST 90Original post

I don't do Facebook either and was able to see it as well. Jake; I assume you are selling/passing on this LN/F6 IMS techno all over NAmerica. Any shop you would recommend performing an IMS'ectomy in the Vancouver/Vanc. Island area of BC? Good on you folks for making Ed's day, but also for raising hope to the non-turbo 996 community at large. Salut! Martin

POST 91Original post

Pretty great result all around!!! Love good news threads - little too much gloom and doom in the 996 world!!

POST 92Original post

Quotes source post: 9923342

We have two Canadian cars here now.. I stopped making recommendations long ago when a shop screwed up a procedure and someone held us partially responsible. Unless its done under this roof we don't know its done our way.

POST 93Original post

Glad it worked out I had my alternator freeze up on a couple cars that I have owned and the belt just burnt lol but they were not Porsches.

POST 95Original post

Quotes source post: 9923359

I hear you! Thanks for the quick reply! My 00 C2 was # ... 0220 off the prod. line in 99 (car bought by 1st owner in Nov 99) acc. to VIN. Do you think my IMS would be a double row bearing that early during production prior to Porsche shifting to single row bearing? Any way one can tell without dropping the tranny using VINs^ Bought the car 6 months ago. Now has 141k km (87.6k mi)! Merci encore! Martin

POST 96Original post

Quotes source post: 9923164

^BINGO^ I'm very happy for the OP but this whole scenario is crazy and the irony here is stunning. The OP has bought into the hysteria and hype surounding these cars and what does he do when he has a minor issue with the car? He assumes the worst and immediately pays to ship the car off to the very same person who is perpetrating most of the fear mongering. But no worries, the masses continue to heap loads of praise on the fear monger and the OP says all of this is a blessing because now he can buy parts/services from the fear monger. You could not make his stuff up if you tried.

POST 97 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Obviously this thread spiraled into the ****ter pretty quick. Forgive me for wanting to spend my money the way I see fit. Good night to all and best of luck with your own cars. Mods, can you close this thread please?

POST 99Original post

When this engine gets torn down, any chance of getting a report back from Flat 6 on what happened to this engine? It would be nice to know what went wrong.

POST 100Original post

I didn't check out the video and the suspense is not killing me. I am however inclined to believe that the outcome for Gator is much better than any of us expected, and I think that is a great thing. No need for me to judge decisions or intentions - a good outcome is good enough for me. I will say however that Jake's ads in the Excellence Magazine are first class!

POST 101Original post

Quotes source post: 9923797

Surely you are mistaking him for someone else...a few posts back Jake said he doesn't do ads.

POST 102Original post

I have my IMS solution if my IMS ever goes: A gallon of gas and a zippo

POST 103Original post

I've yet to view the YouTube clip or go FSI's FB page to learn the real cause of OP’s engine issue, but I’m happy to sense in today’s development that this is going to have a much better outcome than OP had initially feared. However I will say that I am glad someone like Jake and his staff are out there coming up with solution(s), and market them successfuly, it's a business for FSI that resulted from being passionate with what Jake and his staff seem to excel. It’s a free democratic country, if an owner of these cars doesn't think the IMSB will ever blow and won't bother changing it, then don’t, that's the owner’s prerogative and decision, it’s his/her car so no one here is stopping them. Remember SacTownGuy? He is at least one of those who did suffer (likely) the IMSB related failure recently, we won’t know for sure since Porsche again hush-hush’ed his repair through just like how Porsche dealt with other 996 and even 997 engine failures in the past, if these engine failures are not at least partially real, or completely un-related to IMSB, why hasn't Porsche provided the facts and stand up behind their design and product?! I suggest the conspiracy theory folks who believe IMSB issues are 100% figment of Jake’s imagination, should be aiming your anger and energy towards Porsche to get an official statement that Porsche’s IMSB is a perfectly good and bulletproof design, this will conclusively prove Jake to be wrong and Porsche to be right, rather than throwing innuendos toward someone who has genuinely spent the time, expense, and energy to develop products and services that can help minimize this potentially catastrophic issue. Hopefully the thread and posts will continue under positive lights, it has been an educational couple of days reading through the posts.

POST 104Original post

Quotes source post: 9922574

LOL, just watched the video... happy ending... (and to answer my own question, I won't spoil it but that was not his return pump...)

POST 105Original post

Quotes source post: 9923828

That's (allegedly) my plan exactly!

POST 106Original post

Quotes source post: 9923841

Lets not miss the point here. The title of the thread was "Another 996 down". That speaks for itself. Turns out, it wasn't a catastrophic failure and nothing to do with the IMS. Billyboy...remember him? Not the IMS. SacTown, yes. One out of how many. No one can say. To call those of us that don't believe the IMS hype "conspiracy theorists", well, that's like saying I am crazy for not believing in Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster (from MY perspective). To focus my "anger and energy towards Porsche" to get them to admit they don't have a problem--that I believe they don't have...convoluted logic at best. I totally agree with your statement that we are all free to believe what we want to believe. I believe that yes, these engines fail. Yes, sometimes it is an IMS issue. Sometimes it is a cracked head. Sometimes it is a chain tensioner. But the reality is that all cars fail 100% of the time. I just don't believe in putting a band aid on my finger just in case I get a cut. It certainly doesn't mean I don't think you should either. If it makes you sleep well at night, go for it. And like I said before, Jake's marketing is excellent.

POST 107Original post

What have I learned from this thread? The IMS in Gonzo911's and DreamCarrera's 996s will never, ever fail.

POST 109Original post

SacTown - lucked out - Porsche paid in full for his crate motor - yes he had to pay labor. Still don't know the details, but it was mentioned that the car had "major" engine work done shortly before he purchased it. I don't think his case is the norm yet Porsche provided a free engine on a used car well out of warranty. The servicing dealer, who I assume performed the "major" engine work, certainly had something to do with that. And, SacTown was well of aware of the "IMS Issue" yet posted more about his interest in mods and audio units - until the engine failed. I am not a disbeliever in engine failure, just as I am not a disbeliever that lightning strikes people and some of those people die. I still drive all of my cars, I still go outside in the rain. And I am somewhat taken aback by how quickly Jake resorts to feigning that he is offended and "out of here" when he is quite outspoken and his accusitive remarks of "vendor haters" and some other less than appreciative descriptions of the members of this community. He is out of here on one thread and appears immediately on another. If he is not marketing to some degree I wonder why he responded to a member who was asking for a cut away view of an AOS by saying "yes, there is one" - " it's in my new book, you'll need to wait until it comes out". Not trying to spin things up but let's call it as it is. Doesn't mean it's bad or that it's wrong, but it is what it is. Sometimes the "it's coming, something is coming, wait for it, it's coming and it's great, and I'm so busy you'll be lucky to be able to do business with me" reminds me of Apple's iPhone marketing. They are genius at creating artificial demand, selling before the product can be seen, selling more than they can fulfill, and having people feeling priveleged if they can actually purchase AND receive one. Their numbers prove that their "marketing" works. There is nothing wrong with marketing - but again - it would be nice to call it what it is rather than to deny it and act like the involvement is altruistic. In this case Jake could have divulged what he discovered about Gators engine, yet he directs us to his facebook. I personally have no interest in facebook so I guess I'll turn in and hope I awake for another day of enjoying my 60 mile round trip work commute in one of my 996's.

POST 110Original post

Quotes source post: 9924403

Here's one... From: https://rennlist.com/forums/996-foru...res-later.html <cough> another one from... https://rennlist.com/forums/boxster-...diaphragm.html Quite the thread we have here.

POST 111Original post

What kind of a car community is this when, those that know the most, flat 6 in this case, is only willing to release information, in a halfly answerd way, and is always based around money?

POST 112Original post

While majority of us own a Porsche as a hobby, it should be obvious FSI is a business, a business is in the business of making money, it's not even a non-profit organization. I might not like the price being asked, but i can't fault FSI for rightfully charging for intellectual knowledge the company invested its own time and expense to develope.

POST 113Original post

A very instructive tale. I remember wondering when this thread first started why the dearth of diagnostic investigation instead of the rush to conclude that the motor was toast? I just had to replace an a********r on one of my other vehicles too… I am glad for the OP that it turned out to be something completely different. In his case it apparently was not a whole lot more cost for him to have it transported to Flat-6 than to an alternative garage. However, for those of us further afield it still makes sense to have normal, basic, diagnosis done prior to rushing to a conclusion. Many of the more “diy” folk on here could/would have figured this one out on their own, or certainly any competent garage would have. The funniest part was that I had to go to Flat-6’s Facebook page to discover the big secret by watching a video. There is much truth to the sentiment that they are master marketers. I have come to the same conclusion myself. It does not negate the fact that they do great work, but, as another poster put it, “it is what it is”.

POST 114Original post

Glad it was a happy ending for OP. The Porsche belt tensioners must be REALLY effective.

POST 115Original post

I think this thread is priceless. Only the regular followers are gonna read through 9 pages of "he thinks, she thinks" so it's only relevant for those that have an opinion. It hasn't turned negative yet but there's still opportunity for Goodwin's Law to prevail! It was a good read, fun to follow, great outcome (because $300 shipping is a bargain, because that about cheapest I could get to ship anywhere, let alone the most knowledgeable on the continent).

POST 116Original post

One thing that is a fact is that Gator's avatar is hot.

POST 117Original post

Quotes source post: 9924618

Logray, Thanks for the photos. I was the member looking for a cutaway photo. It should really help. I'm still trying to figure out where the coolant resides in the AOS. It appears that it is only on one side of the diaphragm. I can't really see how that helps the AOS function... If the rubber membrane fails, then there is the potential for an intermix issue. Best, TomF

POST 118Original post

Quotes source post: 9923433

I recently had the LN IMS retrofit done on my 2000 C2. It had a dual row bearing made in Japan. Chances are good you have the same?

POST 119Original post

Quotes source post: 9925679

I'm going to cut my old one apart and figure out how it all works but my guess right now, is that the coolant is only circulating in the diaphram housing to keep it from freezing up.

POST 120Original post

Yes AFAIK the coolant is to keep the AOS from freezing. There is not much chance for intermix from the AOS because it is vacuum/gravity operated and lack of pressure, unlike the oil cooler which is driven by the oil pump. With the AOS, you might get some residual/light intermix goop (around connectors from condensation or leaks), but likely not full blown intermix like you would see with cracked heads or oil coolers. The common symptom from AOS failure are tons of white smoke from the tailpipes and difficulty removing oil filler cap. A failed AOS and UOA could show coolant in oil, but not oil in the coolant due to pressure differential.

POST 121Original post

Quotes source post: 9925953

So I am wondering if it is acceptable to bypass the cooling circuit on the aos if there is no chance of freezing. It would be useful to pressure-test the coolant circuit on the AOS. This seems that it would be simple- take the two hoses that go to the AOS, put a pressure gauge on one hose, cap the other and charge the circuit with air. The AOS has to be able to hold a considerable amount of pressure. A leak in the diaphragm would be easy to detect. What I am seeing in my coolant is more of a goop and not the milkshake that everyone speaks about. I am starting with the simplest items, AOS (which is new), then oil cooler and working my way to the dreaded cracked head... You may recall that I suddenly had intermix-like symptoms immediately after changing my AOS.

POST 122Original post

Yes there was a write up recently on RT where someone did what you describe regarding the pressure test. I would also retrace your AOS connections, it does have connections for both oil and coolant as you know and they must go in exactly the right places. Although it would difficult/hard to imagine "plugging in" an oil connector into the coolant hose and vice/versa. And as it is only a $100 item and not terribly difficult to replace (just a minor pain), perhaps get a warranty replacement and swap it out again, they can have cracks and could have just been bad from the get go. More common intermix culprits are oil cooler and cracked heads. FYI I dug up the post from a very knowledgeable person regarding the operation of AOS and intermix possibility (I won't reveal his exact occupation but I can say he has a close relationship with Porsche): http://www.renntech.org/forums/topic...s/#entry210285 edit: I also edited my post that you quoted for accuracy, I'm not 100% on this but the intermix residue probably totally unlikely from AOS (read above post for explanation). i.e.: AOS failure, oil in coolant = nope / coolant in oil = possible.

POST 123Original post

Quotes source posts: 9923930, 9924403, 9925637

I agree wholeheartedly. However I also don't hear about engines from other automotive marques grenading in the frequency and the mileage of what has come up for discussion unless an engine had been very mistreated through neglect or intentional abuse, I can't remember the last time I heard about engine self-destructing with basic everyday cars from ANY marque with ANY recognizable pattern, let alone the failures with IMSB, cracked cylinder head, and chain tensioners which seemed to have shown to have a real potential of occurring with the 1999-2008 engines. As for the band-aid analogy, that is really not a fair comparison, I’d like to think it’s more akin to getting a better helmet when biking because the older, lesser quality helmet might crack and cause me injury if I wiped out one day, especially if some, however few, of these helmets have cracked under similar situations. And yes at that point I WILL sleep better at night. And in the helmet scenario, the particular helmet manufacturer would likely have been forced to recall the less quality helmets, but we won't go there! This I agree, however no amount of marketing/hype for the supply of goods or service will be worth anything if there is no demand. Agree too, which is why I still don't have an iPhone, or iPad, but do have an iPod Touch because it fits my needs. I also still haven't gone to get the IMSB changed yet after owning the car for a year now, not because I do or don't believe it is a problem, but rather it does not seem to be a problem which is wide-spread with high occurance rate to warrant my decision to replace it immediately, time will tell if I will "pay" for this decision. This I agree too!!

POST 124Original post

Quotes source posts: 9927134, 9925637

On this point we are in total agreement! Your avatar has highlighted the most important points of this entire thread!

POST 125Original post

Quotes source post: 9925756

Thanks very much for your input, DB's996! I never thought my question to Jake would get an answer, given how the thread took a tangent at the moment I posted, so your input is a bonus, indeed: Merci beaucoup! The likelihood of running a double row in my C2 makes me feel much more comfortable, but they can blow too as it happened to an acquaintance of mine on his way from Ontario to NY in a 99C4, which resulted in a very expensive tow, back to Canada, and a replacement engine, etc. If I may, did you ever have a chance to look at the old one? If so, did it need to be replaced, although I'm sure you are happy it is? Finally, what was your approx mileage, then? Cheers, Martin

POST 126Original post

My '99 had a dual row too, felt and looked good. Car has 320,000km.

POST 127Original post

My 01 also had a dual row which looked good but replaced with the L&N dual row. Feel like this is the best set up to have.

POST 128Original post

So far I have only heard of one instance of double row IMSB failure. Any one else?

POST 129Original post

I just lost a stock 996 motor last week and I know the pain ( in the pocket) it sucks, I finally got it looking amazing, full GT3 look with o.e. parts including Gt3 wheels to boot, not to mention a $10,000 paint job, roll bar, 5 point and a new Sparco race seat for those "used to be fun " track days. My quest is now, to find out about putting a GT3 motor in a "99 base modle with cable throttle??? Anyone with any ideas ???

POST 130Original post

I just went through a similar situation with my 2002 996. Engine ended up needing a complete re-build. I shopped around a LOT and also spoke to Jake at Flat 6. They wanted about $18K to do the rebuild. I have some good racer friends in Southern California who recommended Vision Motorsports in Laguna Hills. Dwain there did the rebuild, including a new RMS bearing and other "mods" for around $12K. Fantastic work, impeccable attention to detail and a really upstanding guy who took the time to talk me through all my angst. I highly recommend him, even though I live in GA ans had to ship the motor across the country. (By the way, Flat 6 said their next open date to start working on my motor was sometime in MARCH, 2013! I couldn't wait that long...

POST 131Original post

I also have a 2002 that suffered IMS failure a few months ago. I am still having a hard time coming to grips with the cost. Flat 6 was about 7-8 months out at the time. Ended up biting the bullet and going with a "new"(and ridiculously expensive) Porsche factory crate engine. Feels good to have a two year warranty but now I have the "upgraded" bearing that cannot be replaced without engine tear down, and the initial quotes I have received range from $9k-$15k. So did Porsche take a flawed design and compound the problem by now making the bearing inaccessible? I will not be around to find out. I just don't have it in me (or in my checking acct) to pony up ANOTHER five digit payment to keep a $25k car on the road. I guess it's time start shopping for my next 911...this time with a dry sump as well, so I can kill two 996 birds with one stone.

POST 132Original post

VERY interesting. Intricate failures on 996 cars....good to get such great repsonses. Way to go, all.

POST 133 / ORIGINAL POSTEROriginal post

Update to my original thread start. This update has nothing to do with any IMSB issues as my car had none. After a few weeks, my 996 is home from Flat 6 Innovations and running beautifully. Jake Raby and his team performed some maintenance items that needed to be done to include: RMS, clutch, water pump, IMS retrofit with spin on filter and magnetic plug, AOS, etc. Prior to sending my car to Flat 6 I did my due diligence and researched them...as I would with any company that I plan on doing business with. I chose to send my car there based on my research and findings. I am glad I did. My experience with them was nothing short of uber professional. I want to thank Jake Raby, Dean and all of the Flat 6 team for their unbelievable honesty and integrity, not to mention their mechanical skills. I now have a car that I have full faith in and can enjoy for many years to come. I am sure that I will be accused by some of being a poster boy for Flat 6 Innovations and part of their wicked and evil marketing scheme. Not the case. When I am treated by a company with unparalled honesty, professionalism and communication, I will sing their praises. Contrary ,if I had been treated differently and shafted so to speak by Flat 6, I would post that as well. Our cars are expensive to maintain so it is paramount that you do your own research when you need repairs. Don't take my word for it. I am simply one extremely happy customer and would say so if I wasn't. Thanks again Jake and Flat 6! Happy motoring to all.

POST 134Original post

Quotes source posts: 10000750, 10000750

Not by me. Jake's work is an important contribution to the community and the board, but his tone can get tiresome. People just have to remember two things: One, he is selling something, for a profit, and this is not a crime. And two, he spends every waking moment with broken Porsches and their angry owners. That's going to skew anyone's perspective. We just have to filter for that. An important reminder. The low cost of buying one makes people forget that these are still low volume, partially hand-assembled cars built by a struggling company. When a manufacturer doesn't do enough volume to fully develop a product before it goes on sale, the cost gets passed on to the owners. I think my car, which has been trouble free, currently costs me 15% of its value per year for routine maintenance and insurance. That's life with an aging European sports car.

POST 137Original post

Quotes source post: 10000778

+996 and Gator, I'm glad things worked out and knew off the bat that you would not be dissappointed.

POST 138Original post

+1 Love my F6 3.6 build (and the way Jake's team handled it)

POST 139Original post

Gator, Thanks for those kind words. We treat each Porsche enthusiast the same as we would expect to be treated if the roles were reversed. Thats easy, since we are all Porsche owners ourselves. I have a strong work ethic and a direct way of communicating, which often times in today's world isn't appreciated. Everyone is so accustomed to being "stroked" these days and told just what they want to hear that they find my ways too abrasive. I guess its all about those unicorns jumping over the rainbows today and when people experience something different than that, it appears to be foreign. Proud to be different and will never conform.

POST 140Original post

Good to hear you are back on the roads better than ever!

This is a source reference. Confirm exact model applicability in the original material.