Considering a low mileage 911 996 however half the services are DIY?

I've been to see a 996 manual with 28k on the clock, genuine miles. Stupidly, I failed to ask for proof of service in the book before setting off. When I arrived it transpired that from 16k the chap had serviced it himself...I was pretty miffed. My gut feeling is to walk away, since it's a lot of money, but condition seems excellent. It occurred to be that if I started using a good Porsche garage to start services, with 5+ years that early "blip" will be less of an issue? All MOT history is amazingly clean, only one advisory for a tyre. Thoughts??

On one hand, you could have a PPI completed by a reputable specialist who could provide an opinion on the actual condition/ genuine mileage of the car. On the other hand, it's a red flag you can't ignore, especially if it's strong money. Seems very odd that any owner would choose to self-service a 16k-mile Porsche.

Quotes source post: 2816567

Very surprising I agree, and really not a good idea. I have asked for details of exactly what was done at least one. I seriously doubt he did the brake fluid every two years as part of the regular cycle, but I right be wrong. I was planning on getting a PPI for sure.

Nothing wrong with a diy service as it’s done competently and with the right parts I changed my wiper blades…

I've serviced my 15k mile Turbo since I got it at 8k miles , I wouldn't let anyone else do it including a Porsche mechanic. As long as he has evidence , that would be receipts for engine oil and filters , anything else is a bonus. The MOT history say's it all.

As long as it’s priced accordingly, and you are happy with the rest of the car it’s not the end of the world. If you are planning on using it properly, you can get it serviced by a decent Indy. If you are looking to keep it as a low mileage minter and sell in a few years, may not be ideal with that undetermined period of history. I would have thought the owner would have documented the services and have receipts for what he bought at the time?

With a car that old, the provenance of its history will be where the value is. He should have a very comprehensive history and receipt file if he expects to achieve a high price without any official service records. Also, you'd want to be somewhat satisfied with his technical ability to carry out the work.

This issue falls in to two camps: 1. Those who know about car maintenance and how to do it and know that a piece of paper documenting it means naff all. 2. Those who don't know about car maintenance and how to do it and rely on a piece of paper documenting it as proof it's all ok. I'm in camp 1. Your future buyer could be in either. Your call.

As above, and elsewhere on this forum, Some main dealers aren’t doing anything that you couldn’t do at home with the right tools and a more sympathetic touch. Reminds me of a car I looked at almost 30 years ago as I baulked at the fact that the owner had stripped down and rebuilt a G60 supercharger whilst at work. I could have died and throttled him both at the same time. It transpired he worked on Tornados and previously on the Vulcan bomber with his area of expertise being propulsion, afterburners and the like, when he told me about the tolerances involved versus a scoller vein charger and the fact that he’d saved a grand and was passing it on to me I bought it, then sold him it back 8 years later. We are still in touch now, my point is not knowing the background of this chaps expertise might be either a blessing or a curse, and then there’s the all important element, which you’d want to see in the list price. Also look for receipts for other items, such as AOS, plugs, coil packs, brake disks etc. if he’s kept it a high standard “sounds plausible with the MOT History” Lastly, if you’re wanting a FSH and this is maybe lacking some folder with detailed receipts then it’s prob worth looking at something different.

What year and spec is the car, coupe, cab, this could make all the difference to value as well as condition. More so than a bit of DIY service.

Quotes source post: 2816568

No mechanic of the numerous I have asked, changes their brake fluid every two years. Brake fluid gets contaminated, it doesn't expire. Not to mention, once the brake fluid is changed, it doesn't matter how often previous changes were made, they're not like oil changes...

An owner who is intimate with the servicing and maintenance of his car will know the car inside out and be aware of potential issues way before they become problematic. A decent chat and appraisal of his car from him wold teach you a lot about these cars and should give you much more confidence in the car than buying from an owner who trusts everything to a commercial garage and likely knows very little about the car imo

Quotes source post: 2816615

You're probably right about what mechanics do but brake fluid is hygroscopic (it absorbs moisture) and this leads to 2 possible issues, corrosion and boiling of the water/fluid if you use the brakes hard and they get hot. I change brake fluid regularly on my cars.

No response to my question about detailing exactly what he done at each of these DIY services didn't bother to reply. I think I'm edging towards the 997.1 rebuild anyway. £30k gives one a lot of choice at the moment!

Quotes source post: 2816604

Indeed. I look after quite a few previously OPC-only serviced cars and I can tell you that probably 80+% of them were not being fully serviced as per the paperwork and invoices. History and paperwork forms part of the picture but condition on the day of inspection / purchase can often tell you more about the car than the paperwork ever can.

I would much rather have an enthusiast serviced car than one with stacks of useless paperowrk from 10 years ago when a main dealer completed the work as fast as possible. Now a decent specialist if you can find one is a different story. My car does very few miles so I'll happily change the oil and do regular maintenance to a far higher standard than some so called specialists, however to ward off the perceived problem in this thread I will take it every few years and have the oil changed and book stamped. I do however, put much more weight on the two inch thick folder of receipts which tell the real maintenance story than the stamps in the service book.

It’s in the same realm as the obsession in the U.K. that once a car hits 100k miles it’s worthless and how much of a premium people are willing to spend on low miles over anything else. From what I’ve seen on the groups the Europeans and US don’t seem to have the same concerns

From personal experience, the self-maintenance wouldn't worry me as much as the low mileage. If you intend to drive the car properly, expect some things to go wrong as certain components will be stressed like they haven't in years or decades. At least that's what happened to me.

A low mileage car is always going to be collectable and command a premium. Agreed a more regularly used one will probably have less problems but high mileage will pull the value down. Mine just ticked 60k on the way back from Le Mans, I will admit to feeling a bit sad its no longer in the 50's, same as I was when it left the 40's a few years ago.

imagine getting a car thats only been serviced at home by pernickety bert or chief - id have no qualms in taking that as a better level of maintenance than a £400 oil and filter service just to satisfy the service stamping................

I would certainly consider buying the self-maintained car. I also maintain my own cars and every time I buy a new car, I end up fixing issues from previous specialists. For a recent example, I bought a 130i and noticed the rocket cover was weeping slightly. The owner assured me that it had just been replaced by a specialist. 3 months later, my wife calls me in a panic because the car was pluming smoke from the engine bay. Turns out the garage had over-tightened the fixings which ended up cracking the plastic valve cover allowing oil to spray over the manifold - luckily no fires. I bought an OEM valve cover and gaskets, replaced it myself and torqued everything down the to correct specs. Job done, no leaks. My advise would be to speak to the owner - even though I do all my own work, I also wouldn't respond to your questions as I would feel like it is wasting my time going into a load of detail. If you were stood in front of the car, I would make you a brew and talk your through everything.

If the vendor was the sort of person you would like to buy a car from, that would swing it for me. And that will be the same when you come to sell it. Yes condition and history are key, but so is the person you are buying it from if they have owned it a while.

Quotes source post: 2818769

Agree. If the owner can instil confidence that he understands the car and the issues with maintaining it, go for it. (Re comments on mileage, I have a '91 964 with 210k miles. Still worth ~ what I paid in '97)

The truth is that, regardless of whether a car has been self serviced or professionally maintained, the most important factor is to know the previous owner. I myself have looked at many fully maintained 996 and 997 cars, which are absolute dogs, finding issues that a standard pro service would never find... how would they know if a car had the early symptoms of Bore score unless they were asked to specifically look for it. On the flip I've seen self maintained cars by knowledgeable enthusiasts that have been so well maintained they are almost better than brand new. I myself have restored several cars to high standard, and then had to see many £££ wasted with a ro service just to get the pre req stamp... that stings. But the main thing to look out for on a low mileage car / low hour boat / etc is just why it's so low, has the running gear been maintained / replaced, because age doesn't agree with rubber parts. Also engines that have only been warmed periodically at idle ... I wouldn't touch.

There’s nothing wrong with self-servicing, provided there are receipts for the parts and a clear record of what’s been done. In fact, I’d often prefer that if I got a good feeling from the seller and the car looked and drove as it should. I do all my own servicing because I trust myself to do the job properly. For the bigger jobs, though, I take it to my trusted independent specialist. That said, at that mileage I’d want to see plenty of receipts and evidence of maintenance. Depending on the asking price, I’d also be asking why the service book wasn’t kept up to date. These cars are approaching 30 years old now, so it’s not always practical—or financially sensible—to have every service carried out by a Porsche main dealer at main dealer labour rates.

I wouldn’t be too concerned about the servicing, provided there were some receipts, but expect some recommissioning costs, my last two 911’s were low mileage and had been in storage, things like clutch slave / master seals don’t like that very much

I've posted a few examples on this forum why service history is irrelevant. My 997 has a full Porsche service history but you wouldn't know from the condition. As somebody here posted a service stamp means they 'may' have changed the oil and 'may' have changed the filter - or just stamperd the book, charged the money and blown it out the door. I just cancelled the service agreement I had with Audi because it is basically a very expensive oil change - anything else they list as an extra and I pushed back - when I pay a service agreement I expect the car serviced ... Anyhow there are a couple of key markers that I use to assess a seller, I start with tyres - all matching, high quality not budget, less than 5 years old, then wheels - scuffed / corroded are red flags, then I check engine bay for cleanliness - I don't like getting dirty so I'm obsessive over it - you can also see issues much more easily if things are clean, check fluids look and smell how they should where possible and make sure to look for evidence that you aren't the first one in there in ages, check out the general appearance of the brakes for wear, check out the underside for signs of scraping or abuse - if the undertrays are missing that's a sign the owner doesn't really care. Check the wiper blades these are small items but easily replaced if bad - again this can be evidence that the owner doesn't care as much as they should. Make sure everything works as it should - no excuses - if there's an issue and the owner hasn't addressed it then this too shows a lack of care - their reason better be good - if they're selling because they're broke it will show up as neglect in most cases. I don't really get upset over interior mess but I won't tolerate damage that is clearly from abuse or wet / damp carpets. Service histories aren't worth the paper they are printed on even from a main dealer.

The key thing for me is if you think the car is good and well-maintained, then pay an indy to carry out a PPI. If you proceed to buy it, recognise that resell in the future might be a narrow group of individuals prepared to consider a DIY maintained car for a considerable period in its history - offset in part if you have it serviced professionally to negate the prior DIY history.

I'd much rather buy a car that was clearly well owner maintained than by any Indie or OPC. It's been said on here many times but a competent owner will.. - take 2-3 times as long to do the same job - they'll apply anti-sieze to bolts they refit and torque them to the book - they'll spend ages cleaning parts to look like new and prevent further corrosion and possibly painting them - they'll spend hours removing a snapped bolt rather than drilling it out badly It's all down to the fact that they own it and drive it and they most likely will dedicate a whole Saturday to changing brake pads when a shop will do it in 2hrs and get it out AQAP. Keep receipts, take photos and date everything and you're all good.

Quotes source post: 2819324

Absolutely spot on, my F80 M3 is full main dealer service, I have changed the oil in-between service requirements, plugs when not due along with other maintenance. First time I changed the air filters the airboxes were full of debris and had never been cleaned from new, recently removed a ton of debris from all the radiators, again never been done . Main dealer services doesn't mean a lot to me, enthusiasts servicing and maintenance does.

I do my own servicing and work, and I know for a fact I do it better than "most" specialists, let alone main dealers. I do however, also keep a blog of my ownership and works carried out which I hope will give the customers some reassurance about the car when I come to sell. This was my 996 blog. (Says Jamie's now as Jamie bought it)... Jamie's Porsche 911 2001 996 Carrera sites.google.com And this is my 997 blog... Guys 997 Carrera S 2006 997.1 Carrera S Maunal Seal grey with black extended black leather Xenons No sunroof Sports steering wheel PASM Bose PCCM+ Carplay and Android auto (wireless) FSH Full engine rebuild in 2023 at 68k miles. sites.google.com Obviously seeing a record of regular servicing is good, but on these it tells you 20% of what you need to know, or covers 20% of what might be needed to get it feeling like a new car to drive.

Just keeping the receipts for the oil, filter, and other parts in a binder would be evidence enough from a DIY owner in the event of a sale. A full main dealer service history still doesn't mean the car has been well kept overall. Judging the car on it's merits is key as opposed to trusting a few bits of paper blindly. In a private sale you should 'buy the seller' to a certain extent. However, given that paper history affects value in such a big way, negotiate accordingly.

Because people have been taught that it matters and accept it without adequately questioning it - they shouldn't - the document where it says 'owner declined work' is generally not there come sale time, for the same reason people in the UK think 100k miles is a cars death sentence - in places like Australia or the US that's barely run in .... go on admit it how many here have anxiety when putting miles on the car lest they reach that magic number. I have a spreadsheet where I record every task performed, every invoice is digitised and stored, no bargain basement parts fluids purchased, I for sure would not budge on price if they use service history as a negotiating ploy.

I'd almost prefer a DIY car nowadays; I bought my car from an OPC with "full service history", including two services in the last six months, and the 111-point warranty check, and still, when the brake fluid came out, it was black. I certainly wouldn't expect a FSH on an older car, and I wouldn't pay a premium for it, as it's never ever full and without the supporting paperwork, it's not reliable.

Unfortunately, the real world isnt a forum of enthusiasts. Resale matters for low mileage cars and servicing by an unknown home mechanic who wanted to save a few quid, isn't as good as a service stamp in the book by a reputable outfit, no matter how you try to justify it. And i speak as an enthusiast who likes to spanner my car, but if you want to keep value in a low mileage car, reputable paperwork isnt just desirable, it's absolutely necessary.

Quotes source post: 2824758

You will split the market, some buyers will see a stamped OPC/Specialist service book as a positive, some won't. I guess with a low milage car at least the oil has been changed every 5k miles or so and not 12k like Porsche say. If a 996.2 or 997 had only had oil changes to Porsches recommendations I think I would walk away. 2 years or 20,000 miles does not exactly scream well looked after to me. Even worse when they are using Mobil 1 which can be shot after a few hundred miles if pushed really hard. Depends what you want to do with your car? Buy it for an investment or buy it to enjoy it and drive it. I agree. If it is for the former, sure, OPC stamps will always be better, but if you start to use and put some miles on it I genuinely don't think it matters.

I actually find that offensive - I am a home mechanic, I am also City and Guilds and BTech certified unlike some of the comedians calling themselves mechanics these days. My DIY is nothing to do with money and everything to do with not trusting those 'comedians' ...

I was going to say, I have used 5 'reputable outfits' over the last 5 years or so, of which 3 I would not go anywhere near again. I'm not going to name names. It is the main reason though that I would rather do stuff myself. I don't really get the servicing thing, it is so ***** simple to do an oil change, change your filters, all of which can be done on the drive, and with a 996 and 997 you don't even need to jack your car up, why do you need a specialist to do this? I get why, playing devil's advocate, but it is a nonsense. I would rather see receipts for an oil change every 4k miles and recorded in the book than see Porsche have stamped it every two years or even worse left the stuff in there for 20,000 miles.

Quotes source post: 2824769

Like i said, i also like to spanner my car. But you need to see the wider picture, the next owner has to convince the next owner that you were a decent mechanic. An OPC stamp or 9excellence invoice speaks for itself. Those documents add value, your signature doesn't, regardless of the esteem you hold for yourself. In my view it goes beyond ability to oil change. When i was down fearnsport, matt would go through the car when it was up on the ramp and find all sorts or advise on wear items. A decent outfit will keep your car maintained better than a home mechanic who's only experience is the car he owns, as they see multiple cars every day, so know better what to look for. Matt would take his BMW for servicing at BMW. Tells you all you need to know.

Quotes source post: 2824769

same, even if I'm not a professional, the reason I do absolutely whatever I can myself is that the standard of service (not just car service) in the UK is appalling, especially considering the prices

Quotes source post: 2824866

That really does depend on the owner, and the garage. Some of the best known workshops also sell cars, and some of the cars that have "been prepped by us, so to the very highest standards." have been far from great. I hope Matt is taking it in more often than BMW say it needs servicing, or he is going to offload it before it craps itself. I think it also depends on the age of the car, I would agree if the car is 5 or even 10 years old, full main dealer history, but as it gets older condition, condition, condition. Some of the most expensive metal has some serious gaps in service history as they hit 30, 40, 50 or older. Mind you, a few years ago, maybe only 7 or 8 years back, I was thinking exactly the same. I think the thing that has changed to for me is the amount of cars I have seen since then that have been seriously tired with full main dealer service history and the amount of cars that have let go, 99% because the service intervals are simply far, far too high. Looked at a 78k miles 530d the other day that is nearly 8 years old, and it has only had 3 oil changes and everything has been done on time. That is asking for trouble. So even if they are the best mechanics out there (75% are not) who love your car like their own, if they follow the mandated service routine you are more than likely to have issues. Take any car, look at the issues on those cars, and then ask, could that have been prevented with shorter service intervals and the answer, 9 times out of 10, is......yeah!

The work i've done on my car is of top quality, i have pictures documented and all old parts and bills for new parts kept for proof. Anyone who knows what they're looking at would know upon inspection the car is exceptionally maintained. A specialist just does not offer the service i'd be happy with. No thanks i'll stick to enjoying doing my own.

Said it before - my car has full dealer history - every single stamp - and it has cost me over £8.5k to fix the 'full service' BS and I'm still not finished, it will never see a dealer again. Service these days is nothing more than an expensive oil change. To make the assumption that any DIY or home mechanic is little more than a hack is offensive and insulting to many of the members on here (granted some are hacks - there are some youtubers I wouldn't let near the car - and some that I would) but I'll support anyone that wants to have a go. There are those that buy cars to stroke their ego's and then there are the types that do so for reasons that don't require external validation - those that demand full service history do so because they don't understand the reality of what that means (or doesn't mostly). Being a 'professional' does not imply being qualified any more than being DIY implies unqualified.

I'd also point out that rather than wasting money paying labour for some buffoon with an impact gun to round all the heads off everything, or snap the bolt then charge you for drilling it out .This money goes towards new parts thus no corners being cut. I like to take the time to clean and lubricate things properly before re fitting, classic example if a clip or retainer breaks due to becoming brittle i'd order a new one , a specialist would use a cable tie.

OPC for a 996 is a waste of money, they don’t see the cars often enough anymore to know how to work on them. I do most of my own work and have a nice document folder. I do find myself putting car into a specialist for a basic oil service at £250+ every 2 years to get the stamp. I guess it is also nice to have somebody else cast their eye over your car / work periodically. MOT history / advisory free is a great way over time to see how a car has been cared for, I put great weight on that when buying cars…. much more so that FDSH

.

It's a common dilemma. My car's previous owner of 10 years just gave it to AutoFarm for whatever it needed during that period, some of the invoices are eye watering... prior to that is was either OPC or Jaz Porsche. I got my PPI & borescope done at AutoFarm and also my first major service, but been DIY since then with BG44K in final tank before Mahle filter/Millers CFS NT+ and UOA each time. This year I looked at the service book and thought about the perception that a future buyer may have, i.e. "this guy stopped looking after it"... couldn't be further from the truth, but I decided to take it to Cotswold Porsche Specialist every 2nd year to keep the book up to date, and do interim years myself. Its on 123K now so never going to be a high-value low mileage car, but there's still a good market for well maintained drivers cars and a proven specialist history might be even more important to someone looking at relatively high milers.

WilmslowSi, That regime is precisely what I do but I use Charles Ivey for the major services. However I do have the advantage of having a ex F1 mechanic who comes to my garage for all those annoying three handed jobs and intermediate tasks.

Quotes source post: 2816581

But I bet you didn’t let the bladeless wiper arm snap onto the windscreen and crack it like I did!

Quotes source post: 2816564

Your gut feeling was to walk away, yet the condition was excellent, you stated. So, did you walk away or did you buy the car after these contributions to your post?

Quotes source post: 2826836

He did walk away and went on to buy a 997. N Thread 'New to Porsche, my 997.2 S convertible' 29 Jul 2026 Having been a m4 convertible owner for 7 years I've taken the plunge and purchase a gen 2 997. Paint and interior is in really amazing condition and I absolutely love the sand interior. Also, I notice no reflection distraction on the windscreen before you ask. Recent suspension rebuild, new braided brake lines and new high pressure fuel pump. Brand new AC rads too. Having owned it for 24 hours it's too early to properly compare to the M4 but I can confirm the car feels a lot stiffer which is surprising given it's 17 years old (2009). The steering is heavy and communicative and I love... nuforce Replies: 30 Forum: Porsche 911 997 (2004-2012)

Thanks for the update. Personally, I'm not a fan of convertible cars. But there is a market for such cars.